Filter

Is this really a Mercedes?

After offering to help identify historic vehicles last week, we received this amazing photo. A woman in a thick fur coat behind the wheel of a large and impressive car. Jon, who sent in the photo, wrote that the car belonged to his great-uncle.

He also told us that a few years ago, he had tried to find out what kind of car we are looking at here. There were several suggestions forthcoming that it was a Mercedes. But is it really? Jon is not totally convinced. And that’s why he notes “it deserves wider circulation in order that readers of PreWarCar.com can have a go!”.

So guys, can anyone confirm that this is indeed a Mercedes? Or tell us what you think this woman is driving. And maybe give us some more information about the car.

 

Publiziert:
Montag Januar 31st, 2022
Axel Augspach
12 Februar 2022, 14:55
It is a Benz car 1908 without chain drive with a different body.
--------------------------------
Es ist ein Benz Wagen 1908 keine Kettenantrieb mit eine verschiedne Karosserie.
Weiter lesen
Jon Dudley
05 Februar 2022, 12:03
Thank you all for your most interesting observations. Opinion and evidence does in fact seem to point to the vehicles ( the van as well) being Mercedes. How I would love to know more of the background story of my great uncle's acquisition of these cars. A final idle thought...you don't think that the car was a rather elaborate conversion of the van do you?...no I didn't think so!
Weiter lesen
Ariejan Bos
06 Februar 2022, 12:30
Neither do I, though I had thoughts about it too. However it seems unlikely to first extend a chassis and shorten it afterwards again. The van obviously has a shorter chassis than the sports tourer. So for the moment my idea is that they were two different cars. To understand more about the reason for these conversions, we would have to dive deeper into mr. Hawke's world of business and leisure.
Weiter lesen
Ariejan Bos
01 Februar 2022, 11:15
Although only few details are visible pointing at the origin of the car, these seem to be enough to assume that we deal with a Mercedes. One of these details is the side lever configuration, in fact lying on top of the frame. Very characteristic is the bracket, which can just be seen disappearing in the hole of the frame cover, attached to the brake cable for the right rear wheel. At the position of the hole at the lower part of the gate triangle a bar is crossing the frame, where a similar bracket is attached to a brake cable for the left rear wheel. Other Mercedes details are the outward bent rear dumb-irons and the satellite wheel on the steering wheel. The curve of the front dumb-irons is difficult to determine, but could be the shape of an older type of Mercedes. The only other visible technical detail is the large (uncovered) fly-wheel.
Although details of the body (the wheels and the chain case) are typical for Gordon Watney alterations of older racing cars, the body itself doesn't have the G.-W. appearance: it is high, unelegant and rather crudely made. The mudguards are not of the wing-like G.-W. type, but have more an American roadster appearance. The extension at the top of the radiator is more a thing of fashion than of function, and can be observed at different makes.
The above mentioned technical details could point at an earlier, high powered Mercedes (e.g. the 90hp of 1905/1906), but to end up with this car the chassis must have been lengthened substantially.
Weiter lesen
Tyrone Hopes
31 Januar 2022, 18:33
The cowling at the centre top of the radiator was apparently a trademark of a Gordon Watney makeover, circa 1914. The steering wheel design, position, handbrake / gear lever controls and chain guard are the same as those on a Mercedes 6.8 litre in Boddy's book 'Brooklands Giants page 72. Watney seems to have done what many still do today - convert saloons to racing tourers, as they fetch more money on the forecourt!
Weiter lesen
Mike Hill
31 Januar 2022, 17:02
Have found an image online for what seems to be this very car, captioned;- '1912 45 hp Mercedes with aluminium Gordon Watney body, with Count Zbrowski at the wheel'.
Weiter lesen
Jeroen Booij
02 Februar 2022, 09:39
That is the same, well done!
Weiter lesen
Ariejan Bos
02 Februar 2022, 14:39
I'd say it is not. Almost everything is different: body, mudguards, dumb-irons. As I mentioned above, the wheel covers and chain case are similar, but definitely not identical.
Weiter lesen
Jeroen Booij
02 Februar 2022, 17:07
You are absolutely right and I was too quick! But there's more than a resemblance between the two.
Weiter lesen
Mike Hill
31 Januar 2022, 16:51
A Gordon Watney Mercedes conversion/update possibly?

Mike.
Weiter lesen
Josef Boers
31 Januar 2022, 14:28
Der Kühlerform nach ist das wohl kein Mercedes, sondern ein Benz aus der Zeit um 1908 - 1910 (sogen. Prinz- Heinrich-Wagen), die allerdings keinen Kettenantrieb hatten (der "Blitzen-Benz" jedoch hatte Kettenantrieb!?).
Weiter lesen
Jill Copper
31 Januar 2022, 14:24
The car was based in Leicestershire and the owner, Ernie Hawke, was a well known local miller and corn dealer.
My guess is that this is a mid 1920s picture. Here's another of his vehicles which I also posted on PWC some time ago...he liked chain drive!
Weiter lesen
Ariejan Bos
02 Februar 2022, 14:35
Again obviously an older Mercedes, my guess would be around 1908, and possibly (again) an old racer.
Weiter lesen
Jeroen Booij
02 Februar 2022, 09:50
Another cracking car, thank you Jill!
Weiter lesen
Nick
31 Januar 2022, 11:07
The cleverly enclosed chain drive and unusual wheel rims say Mercedes to me but the cowl atop the radiator is confusing - although if one imagines the radiator without it, the sculpted angles also say Mercedes.
Weiter lesen
Jeroen Booij
31 Januar 2022, 09:51
What a machine! Recollections of a lost Blitzen Benz story here at PreWarCar many years ago come to mind...
It would be good to know where John's great-uncle was based.
Weiter lesen

Kommentar abgeben...


Melden Sie sich an, um Ihre Reaktion direkt zu veröffentlichen

Bilder zu Ihrer Reaktion hochladen