Filter

French vs. British: which light tourer do you choose?

 

The summer has finally arrived and so we get our cars out. Unfortunately, not all restoration work is finished, and an extra car is therefore necessary. The amount of space in your garage is limited and so you have to choose a small, light car. That type of car will fit anyway. The next choice that has to be made: French or British? Salmson or Austin? In the upcoming Leominster sale of Brightwells, this question is for you to answer. Among all the cars that are for sale there, 2 little tourers got our attention. A 1927 Salmson VAL 3 Tourer and a 1933 Austin Seven Tourer.

Although they are not entirely in the same price range, we would like to compare the two cars.

The Austin is the smaller one of the two and is an older restoration. Probably the best-known car of the two and will always put a smile on your face. The perfect car to drive to the local pub. And if you stop using it, your (grand-)son/ daughter can learn how to drive a pre-war car, just like you did back in the days.

tn_DSC_2879_3(1).jpg     tn_DSC_2869_5.jpg

The Salmson, on the other hand, is a bit more flamboyant, a true French car. It has a rear screen for the comfort of the passengers and a slightly larger engine which gives you just that extra power to go to the boulangerie. The Salmson is less known as some other car manufacturers, but we can tell from experience that it is a great car to have and to drive.

tn4_53.jpg     tn11_46.jpg

We are interested to hear your opinion: which car are you going to take home and drive this summer?

See all cars for sale at the Brightwells auction here.

Photographs courtesy Brightwells.

Publiziert:
Donnerstag Mai 10th, 2018
Bernie Jacobson
13 Mai 2018, 14:01
Sadly you have overlooked what is possibly the most ignored of the early 1920's light cars as defined by the Light Car Section of the VSCC. I am referring to the Italian 1920/22 Fiat 501. Anyone who has owned or even worked on one of these delightful vehicles can but agree. Perhaps over looked by many, the earlier, narrow track, 501 is in my humble opinion the best of the early vintage light cars. As with all the 501/503 Fiats they are fitted with a four cylinder, side valve engine of just under the requisite 1500cc. But you really do need to look deeper into the engine. Unlike the majority of "light cars" the Fiat has a three main bearing crankshaft with full pressure lubrication. The crank is fully machined as are the connecting rods. In addition the Fiat 501 is fitted with a four speed gearbox with sensibly spaced ratios. This is connected to a smoothly operating right hand gear change. As is common with light cars of the period the brakes are on the rear wheels only however these operate in drums of extremely generous proportions with separate shoes for the foot and hand brake, certainly in marked contrast to the Austin. Having never owned or driven a Salmson I cannot comment on it. However I have in the past owned and driven a number of Austin Sevens.
Finally the Fiat 501 is a full 4 seater car offering a degree of comfort that Austin Seven owners can only dream about. Fiat owners clubs around the world can offer mechanical advice and both new and secondhand parts to 501 owners on the rare occassions that they may be needed.

Bernie Jacobson
Weiter lesen
Tony Hillyard
10 Mai 2018, 08:57
Of the two cars, the Austin 7 has to take first place on the list. Having lived in France now for the last seventeen years, my experience of British v's French cars has to be put into perspective. When it comes to spare parts British cars and their parts availability are light years ahead of their French counterparts. That is one of the reasons that British cars are so popular around the world.

The the vintage / collector car parts industry in the UK is so sophisticated and reliable, with fair pricing. Their customers demand good service and efficiency. So the industry responds.

In France, on the other hand, supplying old car parts is still an add hoc cottage industry. The few companies involved tend to be slow, unreliable and the parts expensive. Sadly, all the time their customers accept their lax casual service it will never improve.
Weiter lesen
de backer francois
10 Mai 2018, 02:56
Owner of Salmson cars since 1964 (2300S and G72). I like them and association of other owners. Nice motor and cotal gearbox.

Weiter lesen

Kommentar abgeben...


Melden Sie sich an, um Ihre Reaktion direkt zu veröffentlichen

Bilder zu Ihrer Reaktion hochladen