Filter

Back to back: Citroën or Peugeot Roadster?

Oh yes, we could easily compare the two Mercedeses (a 1928 630K model and a 1934 380K), since they in the same 6-figure price league, here. Or a 1912 Berliet 15HP and a 1913 FIAT 12/15 HP, not so much for the cars themselves as for they are also estimated very similarly. All from Bonhams’ Autoworld Autumn Sale on the sixth of this month. But let’s do it slightly differently.

Say that you’d be in the market for a mid- to late-1930s French roadster and had the choice between a genuine but slightly modified Citroën Traction Avant Cabriolet of 1937 or a not quite so genuine but never the less beautiful Peugeot 402 Darl'Mat of 1938. They are considered to sell at just about similar prices but that’s where the similarities end. What would be the one of your choice?

To take a slightly closer look and start with the Citroën, we can say the car started life as a 7C Cabriolet. Not much seems to be known about its early history, but we do know it was restored by Carrosserie Bagate Paulin in St Girons in its native France in the early 2000s. During this restoration, the car was uprated with 1.9-litre 11CV engine. When the restoration was finished the car made it over to Belgium and received a good deal of tender loving care from its new owner, who managed to get it starred in a Belgium television series. When he passed away in 2015, his daughter kept it for another few years but has now decided to sell the car.

Over to the Peugeot. A 1938 402, as we said, although it is perhaps not quite what it appears to be. Just 105 of the dramatically shaped and Pourtout bodied Darl’Mat roadsters were built originally between 1936 and 1939 – this is not one of them. In fact, it is a replica based on a 1938 402 Légère (‘Lightweight’). It must be the most faithful one you can think of, though. As a matter of fact, the current owner of this example had been restoring an original Darl’Mat when he came across this Légère and realised that its chassis was identical to the one of the roadster. The roadster’s body was copied and fitted to the restored 402 chassis. Apart from that, some rare tuning parts were fitted: high-compression head, twin Solex carburettors and Memini intake manifold. Desirable, no doubt.

But which to choose from these two modified roadsters..?

Words by Jeroen Booij. Pictures courtesy of Bonhams Motor Cars.

 

Publiziert:
Dienstag September 1st, 2020
Eugenio Lai
05 September 2020, 12:16
Nice to know, Bonhams have now changed the description of the Citroën:
"Please note that upon close inspection by a Bonhams specialist we have discovered this car is a later conversion based on a 7C saloon. The vehicle is now offered without reserve."
Weiter lesen
Joop Terpstra
03 September 2020, 17:55
Hear hear. Before you spend your hard earned cash on a rare Citroën convertible it's good to have a guy like Eugenio Lai for the necessary detective work. Keep up the good work.
Weiter lesen
Eugenio Lai
02 September 2020, 12:46
In fact, this Citroen convertible is NOT THAT ORIGINAL!
It looks like it's assembled with different cars.
Chassis number 93639 is from a 7c from 1937 (from a sedan or convertible can not be known).
The factory-number AW4134 is from a car built between December 1939 and May 1940 - which fits with the body-number under the dashboard - A167062, which is in the wrong place!
Bonhams have been notified several times about this car and so far they have chosen not to react or change the description on the car.
The story goes back "only" to 2003, Is it "Carrosserie Bagate Paulin" who built this car by mixing a sedan, documents from a convertible and many newly produced body parts?
And, then there are many details that are not in line with the year 1937, but that is another matter.
Weiter lesen
Larry A. Lewis
02 September 2020, 00:21
As a long-time owner of Tractions, I'll have to go with the TA and I would keep the 11CV engine.
Weiter lesen
Maurice
01 September 2020, 12:25
Hm, the estimate for the Peugeot is double the estimate of the Citroën...
Weiter lesen
Jeroen Booij
01 September 2020, 16:49
Crikey, it's been raised considerably!
Weiter lesen
Joop Terpstra
01 September 2020, 09:34
Peugeot 402 Darl'Mat is the most beautiful PreWar roadster that was built. So absolutely my favourite. Cheers.
Weiter lesen
Julien
01 September 2020, 09:28
The choice is difficult between originality and beauty and rarety. I would go for the most original one, the Citroen Traction Avant and spent few thousand euros selling and restoring a correct 7C engine.
Weiter lesen

Kommentar abgeben...


Melden Sie sich an, um Ihre Reaktion direkt zu veröffentlichen

Bilder zu Ihrer Reaktion hochladen